Log 9: Missrepresentation

In recent years there has been a surge of brands--usually women's clothing brands--that use body positivity as a campaign to sell their product. In advertising, body positivity means that a company promotes many different types of bodies--typically bodies of different shapes, sizes, and ethnicities. This is a direct response to the criticism of the media's portrayal of women as thin an white and nothing else. By challenging this stereotype, these companies hope to build their ethos and win over consumers who feel as if they can't shop at stores that don't reflect their body type. One of the most popular and successful recent campaigns is Aerie. Aerie is a subsidiary of American Eagle Outfitters who focus on bras, underwear, and swim. A few years back, Aerie formally decided to hire more diverse models and stop using any kind of photoshop on their models. And that's what they did--they feature many different body types and ethnicities in their modeling. They also don't photoshop their models, and they don't position them to look smaller or thinner, either. Many pictures show women with stomach rolls and cellulite. Aerie's popularity can be attributed to their social media presence. They started a hashtag campaign called #aeriereal, which implies that these models are more "real" than non-Aerie models, and that by buying Aerie, you can be "real" too. Consumers are more likely to buy products from body positive companies because of practicality and emotions. Consumers see products from body positive comapnies as practical because many are specifically designed for unconventional body types and therefore fit better and are more comfortable. Many women have had experiences of trying to shop at stores that cater specifically to one type of body and ended up wasting their money. The emotional aspect comes in because people who support Aerie feel as if they are supported Aerie's message--that everyone should be comfortable in and love their own body. Ultimately I support what Aerie is doing and am glad they're doing it. But, sometimes I wonder, is this just another way of profiting off of people's insecurities? The goal of any company is to make profit. Aerie simply saw an opportunity to capitalize on the fact that many people feel insecure when they shop at other companies. I'm glad that Aerie promotes different bodies types and exposes a lot of people to those body types via social media. But I also don't think that Aerie has single-handedly solved the deeply-rooted cultural norm of body-shaming.

Comments

  1. I am inclined to agree with you. I think that they have done a good job in trying to promote self-love. However, I do not think that it has really solved the problem because really all it is, is a ploy to get money. Is there any possible way that we can promote Aerie's message in other ways than advertising that could grab people's attention? Or is it that because advertisements now rule culture, that this is the only way that we can encourage self-love and self-respect?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I feel that this company is also saying that all women are ashamed of their bodies and that they don't love themselves. Aerie is there to tell women that they will love their bodies when they use products from their brand. Once they do that though, aren't women just fitting what others are sating about them? This shows that no matter what women's appearances are controlled my media. I am all for what Aerie is doing and their techniques are, but I think in the end, it is just another way to make money. Aerie is a company, they don't really care about what people feel about themselves at the end of the day, just the amount of profit they made. If anyone should be promoting self-love, it needs to be the people supporting others. Women are not the only ones who can feel insecure about their appearance for men can too. Women need to support other women and men. Men need to support other men and women. To me, this seems like the only "real" solution to keep companies from telling us how to look.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel happy that Aerie is welcoming women with all different body types to be a model for the brand and showing consumers that it's ok to be unique. This goes against all the stereotypical norms that girls feel they need to live up to. But is Aerie focused on trying to get money out of this new campaign? Does Aerie truly care more about promoting messages of empowerment for girls to feel comfortable in their own unique bodies over money? This connects to a few years back when the Barbie company (Mattel) created a set of new dolls that were all different skin colors and body types. The reason why Mattel did this was because Barbie's profits were decreasing as new dolls from other companies were coming out. Mattel needed to find a way to make themselves unique from the other companies and also to receive more profits. Barbie was successful once they launched out their new line of dolls. The real motivation for manufacturing companies to send out these inspiring messages is for money.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think this is a step in the right direction but there is still work to do. The self-love it is promoting is good but there still needs to be a promotion of self-love as a society. The problem with this campaign is that, as other people stated, it is only looking for money. Furthermore, the fact that they are trying to hide their intentions behind a wall of positive PR is wrong as well. If we begin to promote only the core message and allow it to reach all women in society, then it will actually be a true milestone. I think it is good that there is a promotion of self-love, but this promotion should not be based around money. True change should come from an organic change in mindset with only good intentions behind it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I totally agree with you. I noticed Aerie's body positivity campaign when their emails flooded my inbox with ads of unconventional models. My immediate reaction was positive because it did seem like the brand was going all in with this marketing route. They showed models that actually weren't size 2-6, unlike other companies who claim to support all body types, yet show the same 2-6 range. For this reason, I like to believe that Aerie is doing this campaign for reasons beyond monetary value. Their not afraid to use models who aren't skinny and fit, which makes them stand out from the other companies who are afraid to go all out with this type of marketing. It wouldn't surprise me if this was something they were doing just to gain more money, but in order to believe that there is still some good in humanity, I will continue to tell myself that this brand actually cares for all women.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that what they decided to do with their campaign is good, but like you said, how do we know they aren't just doing this for money? I also agree that they haven't solved the problem of body shaming, but that can't be done all at once. More and more companies have to start showing their support, even though it is certain that not all of them will.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment